Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Dear Prudence

Dear Prudie, It has happened twice recently that co-workers invited to our house for dinner came bearing gifts for our two little girls (1 and 3). In both cases it turned out that the "gifts" were well-worn toys my colleagues' older children no longer play with. I said nothing, so as not to spoil the evening, but I do not appreciate other people unloading their junk disguised as gifts on us. Am I being unreasonable? Our kids did play with the stuff, and I admit I wouldn't have objected if the toys had been new. It's just that I feel an invitation is not an excuse to clear out your attic. Should I say something the next time? —Dumped On * Dear Dump, Yes, what you should say the next time is, "Thank you." While Prudie can understand your feelings, you seem to be putting these actions in an unduly harsh light. Try to think "hand-me-downs," something particularly appropriate with children's clothes and toys. Prudie is not sure the dinner guests were even trying to pawn these things off as new. Granted, they might have finessed the situation by saying that their own children had enjoyed these toys ... but they didn't, so work on being less annoyed. Prudie would bet anything they weren't trying to clear out their attics so much as trying to entertain your children with things they felt would be new to them. Give your guests the benefit of the doubt as to motive, and if you really do not wish your children to have secondhand toys, the next time this happens dispose of them, discreetly, when the evening is over. —Prudie, levelheadedly ****** DD says, Dear Dumped, not only do you have co workers who thoughtfully think of your small children with kindness, but, you don't even appreciate it. Instead you bitch because the toys aren't new. Boy, are you a jerk.

17 comments:

Dirty Disher said...

What is bloggers GD problem with paragraphs!? GD Blogger!

miss tia said...

blogger the site must have decided they know more about paragraphs than the blogger person....

maybe you have to enter the html for paragraphs? i'm putting spaces between the brackets or else they won't let me put it in the comments but try < br > with no spaces between brackets br for a paragraph break....

Dirty Disher said...

Thanks, Tia, I will try it. Late for work now. Agggg.

Dan Zinski said...

I have no paragraphing problems at all. Must be you.

Frimmy said...

One time my SIL's (adult and married with kid) step daughter gifted us with a half eaten pizza when my son was born. I thought it was a joke and laughed but she was serious. If she had arrived with nothing I would have been just as happy that she thought to come and see us. I didn't know what to make of the half eaten pizza. I belong to a rare group of degenerates who doesn't like pizza and besides it had olives on it. Gag! It's still the thought that counts, right?

I'm don't even notice your paragraphing problems, DD.

A-Gran said...

I dunno. I think this is weird too. People just dropping off used toys is odd. This isn't a Salvation Army, for fuck's sake! But I'm a horrible, cantankerous, old bitch...

Anonymous said...

It IS fucking weird. If a friend drops by with a toy for your children that their child no longer plays with--- that's one thing.
But bringing used ANYthing as a gift to the home of someone HOSTING YOU is just plain insulting. Better to not bring anything at all.

A-Gran said...

I agree, Anonymous. After you stated it that way I think you're right. It DOES seem insulting to bring that as a gift, although it would be perfectly acceptable for them to ask you if you want it and then just bring it by.

Noelle said...

I'm not noticing the paragraph problems but I'm one big run on sentence. It's not right though get to the bottom of it GD blogger. Crabbie you are so supportive.

Hand me down toys?.....I don't really understand what the problem is. Child plays and enjoys it. Unless it's in horrible disrepair or filthy. Old toy is NEW to a kid. Say thank you and move on. Never know act gracious and next visit could bring 1957 Barbie. (i'm making up that year for you Barbie buffs)

Dirty Disher said...

'59, but, we got ya.

Unknown said...

I rather get nothing than some really used crap specially for a child that young. What is there is small parts? That child might choke on? or get injured. My MIL is big on doing that 2nd hand gift crap, free things in the mail and buying cheep. But it when comes to her or her daughter $$$$$ is no object.

Call me a snob. But I usually throw that crap out.

Dirty Disher said...

Well, I guess others have diff opinions on this, but, I thought they were sweet people and I like hand me downs. From the letter, it seemed to me that Dumped expects everthing shiny, new and in a package. It wasn't anyone's birthday or Christmas, it was just a dinner.

CatsPaw said...

Frankly, I'm with you, DD. More and more, it seems that people go looking for things to be insulted by. Just take the thing and "save it for later" ... then dispose of it if you must. And try just saying "thank you" without manufacturing evil intent on the part of the giver.

Anonymous said...

I used to give my neighbors' (younger)kids my (older)kids' toys and videos when they were done with them. One day we were visiting and their daughter pulled a box from the back of the closet and it had every single toy and video I had ever given them. Learned my lesson. Everything goes to Goodwill now. People are weird about used things. I was just trying to be nice. Screw 'em.

Dirty Disher said...

I wouldn't give anyone stained clothes or broken toys. Some of Lissa's stuff is barely used before she outgrows it. And I am always delighted to get other peoples boxes of outgrown clothes and toys. I guess it's a personal preferance, but, hand me downs are cool to me.

Dirty Disher said...

And in my defense, that letter writer said she wouldn't have minded if the toys were new. I thought that sounded jerk-ish.

sally said...

The letter doesn't say whether or not a hostess gift was given as well. Maybe the colleagues also brought a bottle of wine or dessert or something and the toys were extra. I don't think the letter is saying the toys were meant as a hostess gift--just as gifts for the kids.
And who doesn't know that unless a gift is wildly innappropriate, the polite gift behavior is to accept graciously NO MATTER WHAT. The letter writer is just looking for an excuse to bitch at a co-worker if you ask me!